Skip to main content


The Fourth Way to Nowhere

- the search for cosmic consciousness and the triumph of the ordinary -
a quest for the meaning of life, a critical analysis of the teaching of Gurdjieff and Ouspensky, and my twenty-seven-year membership of a fourth way cult


In this blog I am serialising some chapters of my book, The fourth way to nowhere.

Publication date 7 September 2021
Book links:
or search on Martin Braybrooke


The book is a careful critique of a whole set of beliefs related to, but not exclusive to, the fourth way path of inner development. At the same time it is a personal history of how the author, despite a modern education, got drawn into a cult, and believed (to quote the White Queen in Alice), at least ‘six impossible things before breakfast.’

Those readers already familiar with the fourth way, and perhaps even members of one or other of the organisations that have sprung up in connection with it, should find the analysis in these pages useful and perhaps challenging. There are indeed ideas in the fourth way worth considering, not least the idea of self-remembering, which has a lot in common with more recent movements such as mindfulness. There are other ideas which are questionable, or remain to be proven, such as the fourth state of consciousness or the idea of recurrence: Ouspensky’s version of re-incarnation. No genuine seeker after truth should be deterred from asking her- or himself, “what do I really know, what is merely provisional, and what is likely to turn out to be wrong?”

This is also a plea that one aim of any spiritual or psychological practice or movement should be kindness, if humanity is to survive the various catastrophes that now threaten it, and an assertion that aspirants to self-development can arrive, with the right efforts, at a place where it is no small achievement to be content to being ordinary.


As Alice might have said, “What is the use of a book without footnotes?” The book has footnotes (omitted from the extracts in this blog), sometimes referring the reader to original sources, sometimes to expand on incidents in the Fourth Way school of which I was a member, and sometimes to expand critically on the Fourth Way ideas. 


  1. Lord Sprocket, I have edited your comment because you try to guess my secret identity. Please respect it. This is the rest of what you wrote: "Tis Lord Sprocket here. Enjoying your blog. How do you sign up to it?" The answer is that the widget that used to allow sign-ups has been removed by Google unless I pay them the necessary money. However for the time being I am releasing a new post every Thursday.


Post a Comment

Abusive comments and spam will be removed without explanation

Popular posts from this blog

1: The arousing of thought

“Oh, I’ve had such a curious dream!” said Alice … One day it became clear to me that I no longer believed in the cult of which I had been a member for twenty-seven years. In some respects this parting of the ways had been coming for a long time. In other ways it was almost a surprise to me. I had joined with the belief that here was a teaching, perhaps ancient, which could lead to higher states of consciousness, which could lead one back to one’s own birthright as a human being. I came disillusioned from the peace movement, with the strong feeling that no amount of political protest was going to save humanity from itself, and with the conviction that the only way forward was inner transformation—to start with myself, perhaps to help others to do the same. Thus began my journey from what still seem to me reasonable grounds, into a cult in which the ideas of Ouspensky’s and Gurdjieff’s fourth way were transformed into something different, and in which there was a smell of corrupti

2: Cult versus belief

Link to part 1: The arousing of thought Do not build a Dervish convent or live in one. 
—Abdulhalik Gudjduvani How does a cult differ from any guiding belief? Having been in a cult and come out, I am re-examining what it is I know and what I merely believed.  I was looking for meaning in life, and for twenty-seven years I was a member of what some would call a cult, others a fourth way School—the Fellowship of Friends led by its teacher Robert Earl Burton (‘the Teacher’). Over the years many have left. Many students remain, for the most part beautiful and sincere people. (How people who are beautiful and sincere also appeared to receive with equanimity the Teacher’s prediction that California would fall into the sea and millions of non-cult members drown is an important question. I also wonder about those at the centre of the school who must have known exactly what was going on.) Now I have dropped out. I have read the testimonies of other ex-students, testimonies I had not read

3.4: Fourth state

Fourth state we described in introductory meetings as that state that normally only occurs at times of extreme danger, when time seems to run unusually slowly and there is a calmness and clear-headedness (probably because there is no time to worry or even think). However Ouspensky gives that description for third state. Whereas third state is sometimes described as the state of being able to be objective about yourself, fourth state is supposedly being objective about the universe. Ouspensky writes, “In the fourth state of consciousness, that is, in the state of objective consciousness, we are supposed to be able to know the full truth about everything: we can study ‘things in themselves,’ ‘the world as it is.’”  We used to claim, according to the material in the introductory meetings, that one can, by practicing, be in the third state more and more often, and eventually at will. A person who, by repeated efforts had achieved more-or-less permanent third state might have occasional fou